Our Position

Supervisory Environment

Position

  • ICBA urges examiners to be flexible with regard to bank capital levels and elevated deposits. Stimulus payments and PPP loans created an abrupt and persistent inflation of balance sheets and continue to put pressure on capital positions. This should not be viewed as “organic growth,” but rather an effect of the government’s response to the pandemic that warrants fair regulatory treatment and relief from asset thresholds and increased deposit insurance assessments.
  • Community banks are concerned certain restrictions or practices that apply to the largest banks will trickle down to their level as “best practices.” Examiners should not apply large bank practices to community banks that operate according to a different, less complex, and more conservative business model.
  • ICBA opposes a supervisory process that places community banks at a competitive disadvantage to larger institutions and non-bank financial institutions due to inconsistent or lack of oversight.
  • ICBA supports legislation that would reform the appellate process for agency decisions or actions and allow bankers to appeal to an independent council or ombudsman office an adverse determination made by an examiner in an exam report.
  • ICBA supports regulation that would limit the use of Matters Requiring Attention (MRAs) to violations of law, regulation, or material safety and soundness issues.

Background

Community Bank Supervision. ICBA opposes a counterproductive, adversarial approach to examination and supervision, in which community banks are exposed to legal and compliance risk for minor, inadvertent calculations or documentation errors. Not every minor suggestion made during an exam should be formally recorded as a “Matter Requiring Attention.”

Instead, these should be limited to violations of law, regulation, or material safety and soundness concerns. Examiners should use reasonable judgement and respect in the conduct of exams. A more flexible approach would allow for less guarded interactions and a more productive partnership between bank management and examiners.

Applying “Best Practices” to Community Banks. Examiners should not apply large bank practices to community banks that have a different, less complex, and more conservative business model. Examiners also should not criticize community banks in their final written examination reports for not complying with “best practices” unless the criticism involves a violation of bank policy or regulation. Industry “best practices” should be transparent and sufficiently known throughout the industry before they are cited in an examination report.

Exam Appeals. ICBA supports legislation that would reform the procedure for seeking review of an agency decision or action resulting from an exam, including classification of a loan, an exam rating, or the adequacy of loan loss reserve provision.

Currently, bankers can seek review of these actions or decisions within the agency internally or through its ombudsman’s office. However, these appeals are usually not successful. Furthermore, community bankers often choose not to appeal out of fear of retaliation.

ICBA supports legislation that would allow bankers to appeal to an independent council or ombudsman office that would prohibit any sort of retaliation against the bank for exercising its right of appeal.

Staff Contact

Christopher Cole

EVP, Senior Regulatory Counsel

ICBA

[email protected]

Jenna Burke

EVP, General Counsel, Government Relations & Public Policy

ICBA

[email protected]

Be Heard

Direct grassroots advocacy is essential to promoting federal policies that support community banking – and ultimately impact your role at the bank. Our Be Heard grassroots action center offers a variety of tools to help you amplify your voice with targeted outreach to federal policymakers. 

Learn More

Virtual Advocacy Toolkit

Just like everything else, lobbying is a skill. This toolkit makes it easy to learn the best way to communicate with and engage policymakers in this virtual environment.  No matter what role you have at the bank, YOU can support community banks and make an impact.

Get Started

You are Invited to Capital Summit

Every year, community bankers are invited to attend the complementary ICBA Capital Summit.

Learn More