ICBA - News - News Release - ICBA Opposes Bill to Expand Credit Union Powers
ICBA News Release Header


ICBA Opposes Bill to Expand Credit Union Powers

Washington, D.C. (March 16, 2007)—The Independent Community Bankers of America (ICBA) urged Congress to reject the just-introduced Credit Union Regulatory Improvements Act (H.R. 1537), or "CURIA." This unfair legislation would allow credit unions to further expand into commercial lending and move far beyond their tax-exempt statutory mission to serve people of modest means. ICBA strongly opposes the measure.

"If the large, multi-group and geographic-based credit unions want to operate like commercial banks, they should be subject to the same rules and regulations as commercial banks, including taxation and the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA)," said James P. Ghiglieri, Jr., ICBA chairman and president of Alpha Community Bank, Toluca, Ill. "This legislation is not regulatory relief, rather it vastly expands credit unions' powers to do more commercial lending and would weaken credit unions' capital requirements."

CURIA would permit credit unions to nearly double their commercial lending and weaken safety and soundness practices currently in place. While thousands of traditional credit unions stick to their statutory mission of serving members of low and moderate means, other credit unions are quickly expanding to cover large geographic areas and into commercial lending without paying taxes, complying with CRA, or demonstrating service to people of modest means with their tax-exempt status. A recent GAO study shows that credit unions now serve a more well-off customer base than commercial banks, calling into question their core tax-exempt mission to serve people of modest means, and the rationale for their tax-exempt status.

Other studies, including one by the non-partisan and highly-regarded Tax Foundation, have reached the same conclusions. The new power grab in H.R. 1537 has nothing to do with the credit unions' tax-exempt mission. It would allow such things as financing restaurants or luxury hotels. ICBA urges all lawmakers to oppose H.R. 1537 since it will allow credit unions to stray further from their tax-exempt mission.

"This credit union bill would only exacerbate the inequities fueling the aggressive expansion of complex credit unions, while putting both smaller credit unions and tax-paying financial institutions at a greater competitive disadvantage," said Ghiglieri.

ICBA has long opposed expanded powers for credit unions, particularly the proposal to raise the cap on member business loans, so long as credit unions remain exempt from taxation. ICBA is a strong advocate for tax parity between community banks and credit unions, arguing that a fair and unbiased tax system would apply the same tax treatment to similar industries, economic actions and transactions.

Find additional information at www.icba.org.