TAX-EXEMPT CREDIT UNIONS
- ICBA urges Congress to review the unwarranted federal tax subsidy of the credit union industry.
- ICBA opposes expanded powers for credit unions, particularly the proposal to raise the cap on “member business loans,” as long as credit unions remain exempt from taxation and the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA).
- ICBA opposes legislation that would allow credit unions to raise supplemental capital, and in effect, cease being exclusively member-owned entities – a condition of their original tax exemption.
- ICBA supports applying CRA requirements to credit unions comparable to and with the same asset size distinctions as banks and thrifts.
- ICBA supports the right of a financial institution to choose the type of charter under which it operates, and encourages credit unions seeking bank-like powers to convert to bank or thrift charters.
- ICBA opposes efforts by NCUA to undermine the common bond requirement by encouraging credit union mergers and conversions to geographic charters.
The credit union model has become outdated, and its charter, purpose and tax-exempt status should be reviewed by Congress. Credit unions were chartered by Congress to enable people of small means with a “common bond” to pool their resources to meet their basic deposit, savings and borrowing needs. While some credit unions operate that way today, the NCUA has enabled others to grow their membership and their markets well beyond their statutory mission. As a result, the total assets and membership in the credit union industry have been growing at a vigorous pace, while the total number of credit unions continues to decline.
ICBA urges Congress to level the tax and regulatory playing field between community banks and credit unions. Bank-like credit unions should be subject to the same laws and regulations as banks – including taxation and CRA. Large, multi-bond and geographic-based credit unions have exceeded their statutory mission and use their tax-exempt, government-subsidized status to compete with taxpaying community banks.
Commercial Lending. ICBA vigorously opposes legislation to expand commercial lending powers of credit unions. Under current law, credit union member business loans are capped at 12.25 percent of total assets. Very few credit unions are in a position to take advantage of any increase in this cap. Of the nation’s 6,900 credit unions, only 85 are near the current cap. Furthermore, Small Business Administration loans, as well as any small business loans of $50,000 or less, are exempt from the cap. There is ample capacity for the nearly 99 percent of credit unions below the federally mandated cap to expand their lending with no change to current law if they choose to do so. In addition, nearly 2,000 credit unions are now completely exempt from the member business lending cap as a result of the NCUA’s promotion of the low-income credit union designation. In August 2012, while Congress debated legislation to raise the cap, the NCUA encouraged more than 1,000 credit unions nationwide to opt-into the low income designation, which provides such an exemption from the member business lending cap, under a streamlined procedure. The NCUA’s action circumvented Congress and rendered legislation superfluous.
Supplemental Capital. ICBA is adamantly opposed to legislation that would allow the NCUA to issue rules allowing tax-exempt, nonprofit credit unions to raise supplemental capital, and in effect, cease being exclusively member-owned (“mutual”) entities. Since their creation, credit unions have been mutual entities that serve their members not capital investors. This legislation would fundamentally alter the limited, member-oriented character of credit unions which is the basis of their tax exemption. Mutual ownership is one of the few structural characteristics that distinguish credit unions from most commercial banks. Mutual ownership – along with credit unions’ original mission of serving people of modest means with a common bond among them – was the original justification for their tax exemption.
Community Reinvestment Act. ICBA urges Congress to apply CRA to tax-exempt credit unions in a manner comparable to, and with the same asset size distinctions, as banks and thrifts. Multiple studies have indicated that credit unions are not meeting even the fundamental mandate of their charter to serve people of modest means. ICBA urges Congress to move towards more regulatory equity by applying CRA standards to all credit unions. Charter Choice. NCUA routinely approves mergers and conversions from occupational to geographic charters that allow credit unions to serve large population bases without regard to common bond. At the same time, NCUA has made it more difficult for credit unions to convert to mutual savings bank charters. ICBA supports and encourages credit union conversions to bank or thrift charters, and supports legislation to prohibit the NCUA from obstructing these conversions.